I always switch off my cellphone upon entering a theater. Not just on silent mode – all the way off. I state this not from a place of judgment, or to imply that the specter of a film legend will materialize to offer approval. I view it as one of life's little pleasures: for at least an hour and a half, I am completely disconnected. I leave my phone off for the duration of the scroll as well. It feels decadent to linger as the audience slowly filter out, lit only by the scrolling names.
And, lately, by the illumination of the cataloguing app.
Over millions of people engage with Letterboxd, a film-cataloguing platform. Similar to the Criterion Collection, it has evolved into industry shorthand for a particular kind of tastemaker who champions fresh cinema and delights in revisiting vintage films. Patrons score and write about films, and the wittiest or most articulate reviews become popular, motivating film lovers to put in effort.
"Should I fail to jot down my ideas quickly after the credits roll, my write-ups are far less lucid and well-put," said Josh Stern.
During a trip to the theater, the end titles had just begun before the patron seated in front of me started composing his thoughts. Not far away, a pair remained seated, focused on their screens, noting their individual impressions.
The legendary film-maker David Lynch shared some wisdom: record every spark of inspiration the precise instant it occurs to you. Failing to do so, it could slip your mind, and, as he put it: "Losing a valuable thought, you feel like you could commit suicide." Lynch was addressing hopeful creators, the same principle pertains to the act of reviewing.
Josh Stern, a 20-year-old student in New York, always writes his critiques from his theater seat.
"Should I fail to articulate my impressions quickly once the movie ends, my write-ups are far less clear and eloquent," he said. "The process demands a while. I'm pretty slow, and my partner doesn't like it."
He visits the movies often – 182 times last year – and is on a first-name basis with the ushers, who sometimes need to kick him out so they can begin cleaning the rows. He believes it reasonable to take advantage of the credit sequence: "When you pay for a movie ticket, the end titles are included in the movie."
The app's most passionate advocates attribute the service with reviving interest around a battered cinema sector, where fewer films are made and unemployment is up. (Letterboxd also possesses the sort of demographics brands covet – its primary segment of users is aged 18 and 24, followed by 25 to 35.)
Hype generates more hype; much-hyped movies experience a surge of reviews on Letterboxd immediately after the premiere showtimes. The top comment of an acclaimed adaptation – "Emily Brontë succumbed centuries ago yet this interpretation is still the most egregious event that has ever happened to her" – has amassed over 50,000 double-taps. Another fictionalized retelling generated this comparison to a major artist's concert film: "the Eras Tour documentary left in the dust."
"It's somewhat a compulsion," commented a marketing professional, a 33-year-old New Yorker who is employed in marketing. He also prefers to jot down thoughts during the closing scroll. "Reflecting on what you just experienced, immediately after you watched it, enhances the viewing experience. It clarifies the central themes of a film. Should it generate a sense of a warm hug, that's hardly something you retain five hours down the line."
He feels most driven to review a film if it was very good – or awful. As an illustration: he recently sat through a star-driven film. "I found myself so offended by how profoundly awful it was, that I was excited to whip out my phone and assign it a one-half star rating," he noted. (He is a more critical evaluator than some reviewers, who awarded the film a more favorable review, calling it "smart and entertaining material.")
A social media manager, a twenty-eight-year-old New Yorker who works in social media, watched a fantasy feature at a cinema on the Upper West Side and lingered to draft the write-up ("it received a perfect score"). He has observed poorer etiquette: people taking out their phones to review the movie they are in the middle of watching. "That annoys me," he said.
One of cinema's most enduring urban legends recounts a screening of an early motion picture that showed a train pulling into a station. Cinema was in its formative period and – as per this apocryphal rumor – the shot of a locomotive heading straight toward the camera shocked the spectators so much that people scattered in panic.
Over a century later, cinema etiquette is just as questionable. Often, no one understand how to behave in a theater any more, notably when the lights dim: viewers take pictures of the screen, carry in smelly food, and, as was reported during a blockbuster summer, occasionally get into physical altercations.
A number of users have resorted to social media to debate the propriety of writing reviews throughout the credits. When one social media user